波多野结衣办公室双飞_制服 丝袜 综合 日韩 欧美_网站永久看片免费_欧美一级片在线免费观看_免费视频91蜜桃_精产国品一区二区三区_97超碰免费在线观看_欧美做受喷浆在线观看_国产熟妇搡bbbb搡bbbb_麻豆精品国产传媒

Global EditionASIA 中文雙語Fran?ais
Business
Home / Business / Policies

Rule of law distinguishes China in growth race

By David Blair | China Daily | Updated: 2019-11-11 11:23
Share
Share - WeChat
[Photo/VCG]

The collapse of the Russian economy in the 1990s drew economists' attention, belatedly, to the importance of institutions that enforce the rule of law.

After the Yeltsin government rapidly privatized and marketized Russia's industry in 1992, GDP fell by over 50 percent and corruption boomed as politically connected oligarchs "self-privatized" formerly state assets.

The lesson learned was that marketization without a government strong enough to enforce the rule of law does not work.

The unique strength of China's reform and opening-up process has been that China's government has, for over 40 years now, steadily pushed the gradual institution-building that allows markets to work well. The Oct 28-31 Fourth Plenary Session of the 19th Communist Party of China Central Committee continued this reform push by explicitly setting, for the first time, "promoting modernization of the country's governance system and governance capacity" as the overall goal of comprehensively deepening reform.

After Western economists finally recognized the crucial importance of legal, financial, political, and social institutions to successful economic transformation, the natural approach was to look at how England, as the first industrializer, did it. In the Glorious Revolution of 1688-89, commoners and some nobles rose up against the arbitrary rule of King James II and expelled him from the country. He was luckier than his father, who had been beheaded in 1649 during the English civil war.

The reforms after the Glorious Revolution set up many of the legal and business institutions we associate with the economic transformation of Britain and, later, the United States and other British colonies. These include stronger property rights that cannot be revoked except by explicit legal procedures, patents, a central bank that aims to finance development, equal justice for all people, and a court system that can over-rule executive decisions. Most Western economists argue that these institutions, though imperfectly followed, were essential to the industrial revolution and later economic growth.

However, we have found that effective institutions and methods of governance are particular to each nation. The World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, and other development agencies have been singularly ineffective at copying US and UK-like institutions around the world.

Even the historical record is not really consistent with the idea that these institutions are the universal path to growth. Late 19th century Germany and Japan developed rapidly, but had very different institutions, with more direct state investment, than we saw in Britain. In England itself, the Glorious Revolution was followed by the long corrupt leadership of Robert Walpole, which lasted roughly from 1721 to 1742.

China is continuously developing its own institutions consistent with its history and governmental system. The nation's long record of rapid growth confirms the success of this reform and institution-building process. The Fourth Plenum has emphasized that creating more formal, consistent and institutionalized rule of law is the key to continuing growth.

Tsinghua University economist Qian Yingyi wrote a series of well-known articles arguing that China's economic growth in the 1980s was helped by a decentralized budget and administrative system that forced China's provinces to compete with each other to achieve economic growth. No doubt, this federalism was an important growth promoter at the time.

However, nation-wide goals require national rule of law that trumps the discretion of local officials. For example, spreading prosperity to the country's western and rural regions is an important national goal. And, companies and individuals need a consistent bureaucratic and legal system throughout the country. One key element of the rule of law is that local officials are more tightly monitored to ensure compliance with the law.

Fighting corruption by having clear laws is one key to economic growth. A research report from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development that was requested by the G20 concluded that corruption imposed "significant negative effects on a host of key transmission channels, such as investment (including foreign direct investment), competition, entrepreneurship, government efficiency, including with regards to government expenditures and revenues, and human capital formation".

The Chinese government has been strenuously working to reduce corruption for at least the last six years. This year's Fourth Plenum reinforced the concerns and decisions of the October 2014 Fourth Plenum which also focused on the systematic legal and political reforms needed to establish good governance throughout China. Referring to the anti-corruption campaign, Vice-President Wang Qishan said at that time that the anti-corruption campaign dealt with "symptoms, not the root cause" but it could gain the necessary time to find a way to cure the disease in the future. As this year's Fourth Plenum confirmed, a stronger rule of law is the key to that long-term cure.

Strong, systematic rule of law is also crucial to achieving a greener China. A new environmental protection law that went into effect on Jan 1, 2015, was a huge turning point. The new law was reviewed four times by the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, while the government solicited feedback from environmental law experts, government bodies, local environmental protection bureaus and the public.

The law created a more powerful enforcement bureaucracy, held officials responsible for the environment, and created a formal channel for public participation in environmental protection. Previously, local environmental protection bureaus reported to the local government and were dependent on local taxes for funding. Under the new law, they report to, and are funded by, higher levels of government.

Recent programs to increase legal protections for private and foreign businesses are another move to strengthen economic aspects of the rule of law.

The rule of law with equal protection for all is hard to establish and even harder to keep. In my own country, the United States, many big city governments are corrupt. Right now, filth is building up in New York subway cars because the transit authority fired cleaning workers while hiring million-dollar politically connected consultants, according to union allegations.

And, I'm afraid the elite class of politicians in Washington has become so entrenched and corrupt that they will quash future change and development. As we've seen, they arrange high-paying cushy jobs for family members and retirement jobs for themselves. Lobbyists, who are politically connected people paid to influence legislation, now spend about $3.5 billion per year to influence Washington - up from $1.5 billion in 1998 and only $200 million in 1983, according to data from opensecrets.org. Other estimates are much higher. This may be legal, but it is de-facto corruption that will limit future economic growth.

Mancur Olson, the late great economist at the University of Maryland, argued that economies and societies stagnate as special interest groups are able to protect their positions and prevent change.

China has been an exception to the Olson trap. Following intense study, consultation, and regional tests, China's government has been able to implement policy reforms that have enabled the process of economic upgrading. The Fourth Plenum's push for strengthened and formalized rule of law is the next essential step in the long process of economic growth and institution building.

Top
BACK TO THE TOP
English
Copyright 1994 - . All rights reserved. The content (including but not limited to text, photo, multimedia information, etc) published in this site belongs to China Daily Information Co (CDIC). Without written authorization from CDIC, such content shall not be republished or used in any form. Note: Browsers with 1024*768 or higher resolution are suggested for this site.
License for publishing multimedia online 0108263

Registration Number: 130349
FOLLOW US
CLOSE
 
波多野结衣办公室双飞_制服 丝袜 综合 日韩 欧美_网站永久看片免费_欧美一级片在线免费观看_免费视频91蜜桃_精产国品一区二区三区_97超碰免费在线观看_欧美做受喷浆在线观看_国产熟妇搡bbbb搡bbbb_麻豆精品国产传媒
色综合视频一区二区三区高清| 欧美精品第1页| 精品99999| 青娱乐精品视频| 成人手机在线免费视频| 欧美日韩中文字幕一区| 一区二区三区免费| 91麻豆国产福利精品| 色婷婷久久一区二区三区麻豆| 国产精品免费av| 丰满亚洲少妇av| 免费成人深夜夜行网站| 国产精品欧美一级免费| 国产成a人无v码亚洲福利| 女教师淫辱の教室蜜臀av软件| 久久精品一区二区三区不卡牛牛| 精品一区免费av| 女人黄色一级片| 国产人成亚洲第一网站在线播放| 国产乱子伦视频一区二区三区 | 国产又粗又长又黄的视频| 久久嫩草精品久久久精品一| 国产曰批免费观看久久久| 五月天婷婷丁香网| 国产精品久久三| aaa欧美日韩| 欧美视频在线一区| 亚洲成人资源在线| 国产成人无码一区二区在线观看| 精品剧情v国产在线观看在线| 久久99精品久久久久久动态图| 精品欧美一区二区久久久| 国产亚洲成年网址在线观看| 成人黄色软件下载| 欧美网站大全在线观看| 日韩黄色小视频| 免费看的黄色网| 国产精品国产三级国产普通话99 | 一区二区三区久久| 亚洲 欧美 日韩在线| 日韩免费一区二区三区在线播放| 麻豆国产欧美一区二区三区| 中文字幕第69页| 亚洲免费在线视频一区 二区| 国产精品麻豆久久久| 成人av在线资源| 7777女厕盗摄久久久| 免费成人在线影院| 一起操在线播放| 亚洲午夜av在线| 人与嘼交av免费| 亚洲婷婷在线视频| 白嫩情侣偷拍呻吟刺激| 久久亚洲综合色一区二区三区| 成人黄色小视频| 欧美一区二区国产| 国产成人午夜精品5599| 欧美日本在线看| 国产一区二区不卡老阿姨| 欧洲一区二区av| 久热成人在线视频| 色域天天综合网| 日本视频免费一区| 曰本女人与公拘交酡| 亚洲高清在线精品| 黑人操日本美女| 日精品一区二区三区| 天天做夜夜爱爱爱| 日韩av一区二区三区四区| 亚洲 欧美 变态 另类 综合| 五月婷婷欧美视频| 天天综合天天做| 奇米一区二区三区av| 一本大道av一区二区在线播放| 日本午夜精品视频在线观看| 青草影院在线观看| 日本人妖一区二区| 在线精品亚洲一区二区不卡| 久久99精品国产91久久来源| 欧美三级电影在线观看| 国产激情一区二区三区四区| 欧美一区二区在线不卡| 波多野结衣中文一区| 精品日韩一区二区三区| 91视频在线观看免费| 国产欧美精品国产国产专区| 欧美一级片黄色| |精品福利一区二区三区| 无码国产69精品久久久久同性| 亚洲黄色免费网站| 青青操在线视频观看| 琪琪久久久久日韩精品| 欧美日韩久久一区| 成人性生交大片免费看中文网站| 精品国产凹凸成av人导航| www日本在线观看| 成人欧美一区二区三区白人| 日韩福利在线视频| 视频一区视频二区在线观看| 色94色欧美sute亚洲线路一ni| 国产在线国偷精品免费看| 欧美一级欧美一级在线播放| 91丨porny丨最新| 日本一区二区视频在线播放| 亚洲午夜一区二区三区| 青青草原在线免费观看| 国产精品一区专区| 欧美精品一区二| 国产人妻人伦精品1国产丝袜| 亚洲一区二区三区在线播放| 色综合天天天天做夜夜夜夜做| 国产传媒日韩欧美成人| 久久精品夜夜夜夜久久| 丰满少妇一区二区| 日韩影视精彩在线| 欧美精品久久久久久久久老牛影院 | 国产91丝袜在线播放| 久久久久久久久久久久电影| 国产在线观看h| 美女视频黄久久| 日韩欧美的一区| 亚洲色图14p| 日韩精彩视频在线观看| 91精品国产乱码久久蜜臀| www.17c.com喷水少妇| 亚洲一区在线免费观看| 欧美午夜在线观看| 欧美一级片在线免费观看| 一区二区三区色| 欧美体内she精高潮| 免费欧美一级片| 亚洲午夜三级在线| 欧美另类z0zxhd电影| 免费的av网站| 美腿丝袜一区二区三区| 欧美成人欧美edvon| 国精产品一区一区三区免费视频| 男女男精品网站| 2欧美一区二区三区在线观看视频 337p粉嫩大胆噜噜噜噜噜91av | 成人永久aaa| 亚洲欧美在线观看| 在线观看视频一区二区| 91精产国品一二三| 亚洲成人激情综合网| 欧美一级片免费看| 蜜桃传媒一区二区亚洲| 国产成人一区在线| 中文字幕亚洲一区二区va在线| 一本色道亚洲精品aⅴ| 精品无码av一区二区三区不卡| 偷偷要91色婷婷| 精品国产凹凸成av人导航| 青青青视频在线播放| 成人丝袜视频网| 一区二区三区在线免费| 51午夜精品国产| 精品无码一区二区三区| 国产精品乡下勾搭老头1| 综合久久久久久| 9191精品国产综合久久久久久| 右手影院亚洲欧美| 国产成人h网站| 亚洲精品乱码久久久久久久久| 欧美久久久久久久久| 日韩国产精品久久久久久亚洲| 日韩欧美aaaaaa| 久久视频一区二区三区| 99精品国产99久久久久久白柏 | 大尺度做爰床戏呻吟舒畅| 免费成人美女在线观看.| 中日韩av电影| 欧美日韩黄视频| 免费网站在线高清观看| 成人性生交大片免费看中文| 亚洲综合丁香婷婷六月香| 精品精品欲导航| 色婷婷久久久久swag精品| 成人性生活免费看| 国产精品系列在线播放| 亚洲国产人成综合网站| 久久青草国产手机看片福利盒子| 色哟哟国产精品免费观看| 国产麻豆天美果冻无码视频| 成人性视频网站| 日韩av高清在线观看| 国产精品婷婷午夜在线观看| 欧美日韩免费不卡视频一区二区三区| 久久午夜福利电影| 91啪亚洲精品| 韩国欧美国产1区| 又紧又大又爽精品一区二区| 精品理论电影在线观看 | 深夜视频在线观看| 国产一区二区主播在线| 亚洲国产毛片aaaaa无费看| 国产欧美精品一区二区三区四区| 欧美三级乱人伦电影| 午夜三级在线观看| 国产网站无遮挡| 99riav久久精品riav|